Opinion

They want Australian customers. Why are they cutting Australian tech jobs?

Bunnings, Coles, Woolworths and Telstra have moved or proposed moving work offshore. Workers bear the immediate cost. Australians deserve to know who controls the systems they rely on.

Alphesda InteractiveMelbourne — Worldwide Start a project
An ember key links three system nodes against a dark technical grid.

Imagine spending years keeping a company’s systems working, then being told your job is going. You shut your laptop and walk into the kitchen. The mortgage is still due. The kids still need shoes. You’re working out how to tell your family that the income you counted on isn’t coming back next month. And the company that made that decision will still be advertising to you tomorrow, asking for your loyalty and your money.

That is what a line marked “savings” can mean in an Australian home. When companies built with the labour and spending of Australians stop investing in the people who keep them running, I think betrayal is a fair word for it.

What Bunnings, Coles, Woolworths and Telstra announced

Bunnings. On 17 November, Bunnings announced that around 230 permanent technology roles would be made redundant and about 120 contractor engagements would end. Under its deal with Tata Consultancy Services, more work will be done by teams in Australia, India and the Philippines. Bunnings says it will keep a core technology team of around 500 in Australia and expects the deal to lower delivery costs and expand access to specialist skills. ABC News · Bunnings statement

Coles. In August, Coles confirmed that its expanded Accenture deal would shift some corporate work to Accenture in Australia and overseas, including technology work. Several hundred back-office roles were affected across multiple functions, with redundancy, redeployment and retraining among the possible outcomes. That figure is neither a confirmed IT redundancy count nor a count of jobs moved offshore. AAP reporting · iTnews

Woolworths. In June, Woolworths announced plans to shift some corporate work to Asia. SBS reported that IT, finance and HR were among the areas affected; Woolworths did not confirm an affected headcount in that reporting. It said the move was aimed at improving efficiency as competition increased, and that it expected new stores across Australia and New Zealand to create around 2,500 roles. SBS News

Telstra.In February, Telstra said around 442 roles would no longer be needed if its proposed changes went ahead, with some work moving to Infosys. Separately, its data and AI venture with Accenture proposed cutting up to 209 roles and moving some work to India. Neither number tells us how many jobs moved overseas. A later update from Telstra, published by the Communications Workers Union, said the Infosys partnership was proceeding and 328 Enterprise Service & Delivery employees had been notified of redundancy at that point. That is an update on the Infosys change, not another 328 to add to the February figures.ABC News · CWU update

A country can’t keep expertise it won’t pay to develop

A new job on a shop floor is worth having. It doesn’t replace the engineer who knows how a warehouse gets back online or the senior developer who teaches the next graduate how to fix a broken system without making it worse. Once those teams are gone, you can’t hire their collective memory back with a job ad. You have to rebuild it, person by person, over years.

There’s nothing wrong with wanting Australian workers to have a future in the businesses they helped build. People overseas doing an honest day’s work didn’t make these decisions. The boards did. They should be able to look Australian workers in the eye and say what they tried to keep the work here, how many people they actually redeployed, and what they’re doing to train the next generation.

Who holds the keys when something goes wrong?

Picture a Saturday morning when the checkouts stop talking to the stock system, or customer accounts can’t be accessed. Can an employee of the company revoke the supplier’s access and restore the service, or does the company have to ring the supplier and wait? If the answer is “we don’t know”, the board had no business signing the deal.

This is a serious security risk wherever control is weak. Give an external supplier administrator access and a compromise at that supplier can become your problem. Let the work pass through subcontractors and it gets harder to know who can see sensitive data, who can copy it and whose laws apply. Host the data in Australia and an overseas administrator may still be able to reach it. Cut the internal team too far and you can lose the people who know how to contain an incident or rebuild a system when the vendor can’t help.

The Australian Signals Directorate’s outsourcing guidance flags the risks of poorly controlled remote and administrator access. And as the OAIC explains, where Australian Privacy Principle 8 applies to an overseas disclosure, the organisation generally has to take reasonable steps to protect the information and can remain accountable for how the overseas recipient handles it, subject to exceptions. None of these job announcements proves that customer data was sent overseas, that anyone’s systems were compromised, or that any company broke the law. They are reason to ask what controls are in place before there’s a problem.

What boards should tell workers and customers

  1. How many Australian jobs will actually disappear, how many people will be redeployed, and how many will be offered a job with the provider?
  2. Which critical systems stay under the company’s direct control? Who can make changes, from where, and can the company revoke that access on its own?
  3. Can the company restore the service from backups without the vendor? When did it last practise doing that?
  4. What do the savings look like after the handover, retraining, oversight and the cost of moving the work again if the contract fails?

We expect the businesses that sell us food, supplies and communications to know how to keep those services running. We should expect them to develop the people here who can do it, too. If a company is proud enough to trade on being part of Australian life, it should be proud enough to show what it’s prepared to keep and build here.

Review who controls your custom software, CRM integrations and data systems. Talk to Alphesda if you need help deciding what to keep in-house.

Frequently asked questions

Does offshoring IT automatically make it less secure?

No. A local vendor can have poor controls and an overseas vendor can have excellent ones. What matters is who can reach sensitive systems, how access is supervised, which laws apply and whether the business can recover without waiting for a third party.

Does moving a job overseas mean customer data goes overseas too?

Not necessarily. The people, the hosting and the rights to view or copy the data can all be in different places. Ask where data is stored, who can access it remotely and whether other suppliers can access it too.

What should a company keep in-house?

At a minimum, keep people who own the technical decisions, control administrator access and know how to respond to an outage. Keep the documentation and backups they need, and test whether they can actually restore the systems.

Next step

Ready to turn this into a brief?

Bring your current website, the customer action you need and the work you want to commission. We can scope the website, app or marketing service around that brief.